There’s a spot on Jellicoe Street where the cocktails come with a side of harbour breeze and the decor commits fully to tiki. The Good Luck Coconut has built its name in Auckland’s Wynyard Quarter as a rum-led, Pacific-and-Asian-fuelled escape — and it’s also one of the most confusing restaurants to research online.

4 related posts

Menu Items: 51 dishes and drinks ·
Location: Wynyard Quarter, Auckland CBD ·
Known For: Pacific-inspired cocktails ·
Contact: 09-303 0440 ·
Vibe: Relaxed tiki bar ·
Online Presence: TripAdvisor, MapQuest, Facebook

Quick snapshot

1Confirmed facts
2What’s unclear
3Status signal
  • Google 4.4/5 from 751 reviews; TripAdvisor 4.5/5 from 154 reviews (Wanderlog travel planner listing)
  • Foodeist aggregates 157 visitor reviews in its listing (Foodeist restaurant directory)
  • The same sources disagree on whether the venue is open or closed
4What’s next
  • Verify opening status by phone before visiting: 09-303 0440
  • Confirm you’re headed to the Wynyard Quarter venue, not the namesake Guernsey shop

Ten rows, one pattern: the venue’s core details line up across listings, but its operating status does not.

Attribute Detail
Name The Good Luck Coconut
Type Tiki bar / restaurant
Location 39 Jellicoe Street, Wynyard Quarter, Auckland CBD
Menu items 51 dishes and drinks
Known for Pacific-inspired cocktails
Contact 09-303 0440
Price range NZ$14–34 (indicative)
Ratings Google 4.4/5 · TripAdvisor 4.5/5
Wheelchair access Listed
Operating status Conflicting — verify before visiting

What Is The Good Luck Coconut?

The Good Luck Coconut is a tiki bar with a full kitchen, anchored in Wynyard Quarter at 39 Jellicoe Street. Its Pacific-Asian menu direction and rum-led cocktail list give it a clear personality, but the venue has no official website — so its identity has to be assembled from tourism guides, directories, and reviews.

The official city guide, AucklandNZ, ranks it among Auckland’s best tiki bars in promotional copy — a useful signal for first-timers scanning the waterfront, even if the claim is marketing rather than measurement.

Is The Good Luck Coconut a Restaurant or a Shop?

  • Format: tiki bar with a restaurant-grade kitchen
  • Cuisine: Pacific- and Asian-influenced sharing plates
  • Drinks: rum-led cocktails take the lead
  • Common mix-up: search results often surface a same-named eco-store in Guernsey

The short answer is both: it’s a bar first, with a kitchen that behaves like a restaurant. The longer answer is that the venue’s online footprint is fragmented enough that directories, not the business itself, define what it appears to be.

The Good Luck Coconut in Auckland vs. Guernsey

The paradox

Search “The Good Luck Coconut” and a Facebook page for a Guernsey business selling eco-friendly products can surface alongside the Auckland bar. Same name, different continent, zero visible connection.

The Guernsey operation appears to be an eco-products store with a matching name. No source connects it to the Auckland venue, and the two share nothing but the name — so any page that talks about Guernsey is pointing at the wrong business.

The implication: the bar’s identity is solid in person and scattered online, and that gap is where the confusion breeds.

What Is on The Good Luck Coconut Menu?

The menu is the venue’s most concrete document: 51 dishes and drinks in its own PDF menu, and the clearest evidence that this is a kitchen-led tiki bar, not a prop bar.

Cocktails and Drinks

  • Rum-led tiki cocktails anchor the list, with Pacific-Asian ingredients showing up in the glass.
  • One Yelp reviewer described the drinks as less sweet than at many tiki bars and said they appeared carefully prepared (Yelp business listing).
  • An NZ$8 happy-hour chicken-wing offer has been reported, but its current availability is unverified.

The bar’s TripAdvisor listing leans into that identity directly, promising cocktails that are “some of the best this side of the Blue Lagoon” — marketing language, but it tells you exactly what the venue wants to be.

Food Offerings

  • Rum-glazed pork belly with pineapple and green-chilli salsa (NZ Travel Tips (New Zealand travel guide))
  • NZ wagyu burger with smoked mayonnaise, cheese, onion rings, salad, and fries (NZ Travel Tips New Zealand travel guide)
  • Yakitori salad with green-pepper tofu, plus coconut soft serve for dessert, both flagged by Yelp reviewers

It’s a sharing-plate structure, so tables tend to order across the list rather than one main each. That works well when the kitchen is on form — and the review record suggests the kitchen is not always on form.

Full Menu PDF

The trade-off

The PDF menu is the venue’s most reachable owned asset — it circulates through search results where an official website should be. It proves the kitchen’s ambition, but it can’t guarantee what’s actually on the pass tonight.

The PDF is the closest thing the bar has to an official menu document, and it’s the reason the 51-item count is knowable at all. What it can’t tell you is what the kitchen is actually serving tonight — that’s where the review record comes in.

Bottom line: The menu is the strongest evidence that The Good Luck Coconut is a serious venue, not just a themed bar. Cocktail drinkers should head for the rum-led list. Hungry tables should order several plates and expect a kitchen that’s better on flavour than on speed.

The pattern: a wide menu and a well-stocked bar give the venue its backbone; the inconsistent kitchen reviews are the loose thread that keeps it from being a sure thing.

Are There Good Reviews for The Good Luck Coconut?

Mostly yes, with caveats that matter more than the averages suggest.

TripAdvisor Reviews and Ratings

Google: 4.4/5 · 751 reviews ·
TripAdvisor: 4.5/5 · 154 reviews ·
Foodeist aggregation: 157 reviews

What to watch

Wanderlog’s listing carries the 4.4/5 and 4.5/5 scores — then marks the venue permanently closed. Before you visit, call 09-303 0440 to confirm the tiki torches are actually lit.

That single “permanently closed” flag matters more than any one-star review, because it changes the question from “is it good?” to “is it open?” It also makes the bar an easy skip for anyone who checks an aggregator and moves on.

Social Media and Aggregator Presence

  • Listings appear on TripAdvisor, MapQuest, and Guts’d.
  • A Facebook page for a same-named Guernsey eco-store can rank in search results for the Auckland venue.
  • No owned website or verified branded social account is documented for the bar itself.

Foodeist’s synthesis of visitor reviews captures the split: praise for friendly service, taste, atmosphere, and generous portions sits alongside complaints about inconsistent food, slow service, noise, and prices perceived as high (Foodeist restaurant directory).

Bottom line: The averages are solid — 4.4/5 on Google, 4.5/5 on TripAdvisor — but the “permanently closed” flag changes the calculation. First-timers should verify the door is open before making the trip.

What this means: the headline rating is a blend of two very different experiences — one delighted, one disappointed — and which one you get can come down to the night, the shift, and the queue.

Where Is The Good Luck Coconut Located?

The Good Luck Coconut sits in Wynyard Quarter, Auckland’s renovated waterfront precinct, at 39 Jellicoe Street — a walkable distance from the harbour and the city’s ferry connections.

Address and Map

  • Address: 39 Jellicoe Street, Wynyard Quarter, Auckland CBD
  • Getting there: car, ferry, and tram routes connect the venue to the city centre
  • Neighbourhood: waterfront dining and drinking strip

AucklandNZ’s visitor guide notes the venue is accessible from the city centre by car, ferry, and tram, which makes it an easy add to a harbour-side evening.

About Wynyard Quarter

  • District: one of Auckland’s go-to dining and drinking areas, rebuilt around the working harbour (NZ Travel Tips New Zealand travel guide)
  • Competition: a dense strip of restaurants and bars sharing the same foot traffic

That context is the key to the bar’s survival: a tiki venue works here because the neighbourhood already draws crowds for food and drink — it just needs to give them a reason to pick the coconut over the bar next door.

The pattern: location does half the venue’s marketing for it; the other half is left to the cocktail shaker.

How Does The Good Luck Coconut Compare to Other Auckland Bars?

The honest comparison is less about tiki versus craft beer and more about what you want from the evening.

Tiki Bar Experience and Atmosphere

  • Vibe: a “kick back and relax” tiki-bar energy, per the venue’s own TripAdvisor description
  • Atmosphere: the strength of the room is a consistent theme in Yelp and Foodeist summaries
  • Contrast: high-volume CBD clubs deliver a louder, faster evening

Reviewers generally agree the atmosphere delivers. What separates this venue from a high-volume club is pacing: it’s built for sinking into a booth, not queuing at a counter.

Unique Selling Points

The upshot

The Good Luck Coconut’s edge is focus — a themed bar that takes its drinks and its Pacific-Asian kitchen seriously. The cost of that focus is consistency, plus a status flag that should be verified before you commit.

Five comparison points, one pattern: the tiki bar wins on atmosphere and drinks, and loses on speed and predictability.

Aspect The Good Luck Coconut Typical Wynyard Quarter bar High-volume CBD club
Atmosphere Relaxed, tiki-themed, waterfront Casual, harbour-view dining Loud, high-energy, dance floor
Menu Pacific-Asian sharing plates Pub classics and small plates Bar snacks and bottle service
Drinks Rum-led tiki cocktails Beer and wine focus High-volume mixed drinks
Service style “Kick back and relax” table service Efficient table service Counter service and queued rounds
Spend per item NZ$14–34 (indicative) Moderate Premium
Bottom line: For a relaxed, cocktail-first evening by the water, The Good Luck Coconut leads the district on atmosphere and drink originality. For diners who want fast, predictable service at a competitive price, the comparison points to other venues.

The trade-off: unless you’re explicitly after a themed, slower-paced evening, the venue’s quirks — noise, kitchen inconsistency, and an unresolved closed flag — will matter more than its tiki charm.

The Good Luck Coconut at a glance

The catch

The spec sheet confirms a full-service venue — seating, table service, reservations, a full bar — and then refuses to confirm the one thing that matters most: whether it’s open.

Twelve specs, one pattern: the physical venue is fully equipped, and the operational status is fully unresolved.

Spec Detail
Cuisine Pacific- and Asian-influenced sharing plates
Drink focus Rum-led tiki cocktails
Seating Available
Table service Yes
Reservations Listed
Outdoor seating Listed
Full bar Yes
Alcohol service Yes
Wheelchair access Listed
Price range NZ$14–34 (indicative)
Aggregated ratings Google 4.4/5 · TripAdvisor 4.5/5
Operating status Conflicting — verify before visiting

Upsides

  • Pacific-Asian sharing menu with dishes like rum-glazed pork belly and a wagyu burger
  • Distinctive, less-sweet tiki cocktails that reviewers say are carefully made
  • Friendly service, strong atmosphere, and generous portions in review syntheses
  • Waterfront Wynyard Quarter location, reachable by car, ferry, and tram

Downsides

  • Inconsistent food quality and slow service reported across aggregated reviews
  • Noise levels can run high in the room
  • Prices perceived as high for what some diners receive
  • A “permanently closed” flag on one major listing, unresolved in the sources

One trick cuts through the noise: separate what’s documented from what isn’t.

Confirmed facts

  • Tiki bar and restaurant at 39 Jellicoe Street, Wynyard Quarter (AucklandNZ official city guide)
  • Menu lists 51 dishes and drinks, per the venue’s own PDF menu
  • Aggregated ratings of 4.4/5 on Google (751 reviews) and 4.5/5 on TripAdvisor (154 reviews) (Wanderlog travel planner listing)

What’s unclear

  • Whether the venue is open: Wanderlog’s listing flags it permanently closed, conflicting with activity signals elsewhere
  • Whether the Auckland bar is connected to the same-named Guernsey eco-store
  • Ownership and management details
  • Whether happy-hour offers such as the NZ$8 wings special are still running

Voices from the reviews

Kick back and relax down here at The Good Luck Coconut, where our tiki bar will make you some of the best cocktails this side of the Blue Lagoon.

— The Good Luck Coconut, TripAdvisor listing

Probably one of Auckland’s best tiki bars.

— AucklandNZ, official city guide

Yelp reviewers add that the atmosphere, friendly staff, waterfront location, and distinctive cocktails are the main draw (Yelp business listing), while Foodeist’s synthesis balances the praise with complaints about inconsistency, noise, and pricing.

The final call

The Good Luck Coconut is a genuine Wynyard Quarter original: a tiki bar with a serious rum-led cocktail program, a Pacific-Asian sharing menu, and ratings that most waterfront venues would take. The problems are about trust in the channel — a namesake Guernsey eco-store muddying search results, aggregators that can’t agree on whether it’s open, and a kitchen that reviews say doesn’t always fire on all cylinders. For anyone planning an Auckland night out, the choice is clear: treat the reviews as direction, not gospel, and call 09-303 0440 before you go — or end up outside a tiki bar that isn’t serving, in a quiet part of Wynyard Quarter with nothing on the schedule but the walk back.

Related reading

Additional sources

firsttable.co.nz, firsttable.co.nz, findmeglutenfree.com

Don't miss these

Frequently asked questions

Does The Good Luck Coconut have happy hour?

A Yelp review mentioned an NZ$8 happy-hour chicken-wing offer, but its date and current availability are unverified. If happy hour is the point of your visit, call the bar to confirm it is still running.

What is the price range at The Good Luck Coconut?

Foodeist’s directory lists an indicative range of NZ$14–34 per item. A full evening with several sharing plates and cocktails will land at the upper end of that band, or higher.

Is The Good Luck Coconut wheelchair accessible?

Foodeist’s listing includes wheelchair accessibility, along with seating, table service, reservations, alcohol service, outdoor seating, and a full bar.

Does The Good Luck Coconut offer vegetarian or vegan food options?

The menu includes dishes such as a yakitori salad with green-pepper tofu and coconut soft serve, giving vegetarians clear choices. A dedicated vegan menu is not documented in the available sources.

How can I make a reservation at The Good Luck Coconut?

Reservations are listed as available on Foodeist. With no official website documented, the practical route is to call 09-303 0440 directly.

What is the best time to visit The Good Luck Coconut?

The atmosphere is a consistent highlight in reviews, while noise is a recurring complaint, so an early dinner offers the calmest experience. Evening visits deliver the full tiki vibe but with busier, louder service.

Does The Good Luck Coconut cater to private events?

No source documents private-event or catering services for the Auckland venue. Given the fragmented online record, contacting the bar directly is the only reliable way to get an answer.